Okay. I'm not really that dismal. But I do like the fact that when people come to our home, I can socialize without having to put on shoes or breath fresh air.
A dinner party is even better if you have a theme. Yes, a theme. It doesn't have to be an all-out, everyone dress up kind of deal ala, "Murder At the Copa Cabana!", although that would make me want to be your best friend. No, I'm thinking something simpler, such as a taste test between organic and non-organic supermarket meat.
See, Greenbury Market sent me a gorgeous and generous package of organic rib eye steaks and boneless chicken breasts. It made me wonder, would I be able to taste the difference? Would my husband? Would my friends? And so the invites went out. Soon Jim, Leslie and little Nicholas showed up at our door.
The purpose of this taste test dinner party has to do with just that: taste. I realize that there are many, many socially beneficial reasons for buying organic meat, and they make sense. But this only has to do with TASTE right now. Any more of a full discussion will take too much research and ignite way too much debate for my simple homecooking blog. Read: I'm lazy.
Since cooking the steaks kept me in the kitchen and away from my guests, I kept the rest of the meal simple. I threw the chicken breasts in a glass Pyrex, coated them with BBQ sauce and baked them at 425 for 15 minutes.
For sides I made potato salad the night before. I lifted a recipe from Julie at Kitchenography and did most of the prep for Laurie Colwin's creamed spinach earlier in the day. I also made a big green salad that we ended up not really needing but it was amazingly good. (The secret is toasted fresh pecans and this vinaigrette.)
I should note here that I made way, way too much food. I didn't make enough food for a dinner party once. ONCE. The Italian American police demanded I give back my DNA. We convinced them to give me another chance but it has scarred me for life. Never again!
We loaded up our plates, sat down, and dug into some very serious eating.
It probably will come as no surprise that the Greensbury Market steak had more flavor and a much nicer texture than the supermarket meat. It was a unanimous winner. I could even tell the difference in flavor with the fat. (Yes, I'm a fat eater when it comes to beef. It's mine and my future heart donor's favorite part.) The organic meat just sang with beef flavor on many levels, getting better and better in my mouth with each chew. The supermarket meat just kinda sat there and actually got blander with every bite.
The chicken was a different story. The texture and juiciness of the supermarket chicken was better, but I have to take the blame for this. I cooked the organic and the supermarket chicken together. Because organic chicken isn't pumped with stuff to keep it large and juicy, it is smaller and therefore turned out dry. My bad. I should've cooked them separately. Organic chicken doesn't need to be in the oven for as long.
Even so, we all agreed the organic chicken tasted more like, well, chicken. But the texture awards went to the supermarket brand.
Our conclusion. Better beef is worth the price. And considering Greensbury Market rib eye is $13.99 (plus shipping) to my supermarket's $11.99 steak, there's not even that much of a cost difference.
Organic chicken, however is a toss up. Check your values, your taste buds, your recipe and your pocketbook to decide if it's worth it. I'll leave it up to you.
A thanks to Greensbury Market for the opportunity to sample their delectable goodies.
A thanks to Jim, Leslie and Nicholas for lending us their palettes.
A thanks to the Italian American police for letting me keep my DNA.
And a special thanks to anyone who has read this incredibly long winded post. You are a trouper and I love you. (Mom!)












